Showing posts with label Time Dilation. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Time Dilation. Show all posts

Thursday, August 4, 2011

Trying to Understand Relativity (part 9)

You might recall a while back that I proposed a wave model of time as opposed to the more traditional linear model.  The idea was that time wasn't a line that we traveled on, but rather a wave that swept us along with a crest composed of all the dynamic changes through-out the universe.  Another way of putting it would be to say that time isn't a line or a medium in which these changes occur, but rather that time is the changes themselves and nothing more.  Things are happening in the universe and we are witnessing them, and we call these happenings and the fact of our witness, "time."  In this view, if everything was cleared out of the universe or if all changes in the universe could suddenly be stopped, then time itself would stop.  In this view, there is no time without change and motion.

Ah, but now you've found a flaw in my logic, right?  If the universe was stopped and completely static, wouldn't it be so for a certain amount of time?  The problem is that this question presupposes an observer, who can witness the static universe and perhaps even measure its frozen state with the one working stopwatch in all of existence.  In such an event, it would be the observer and their stopwatch that would be in a state of flux, changing and happening.  The passage of time that the universe remains static could only be measured relative to the observer and the watch.  If we remove them from the scenario, then the universe could stop ...now...and then start again without any of us knowing about it, and the question of "how long" it was stopped becomes meaningless.  There would be no sense in which you could say that it was a fraction of a second or a million years without something else in a state of flux to reference it against.  At any moment, at any prior state of the flux considered in isolation and pulled from existence like a still photograph, we could claim that the universe "stopped" for an indefinite interval and it would alter nothing.  The claim itself would be nonsense.  We would simply being saying, "The universe was like this, and then it moved again."  In the wave model, there would be no point in trying to look for time between the gaps in these changes.  In the wave model, time is defined by the changes. 

Now, in that same post where I introduced this wave model, I also wondered, if it was true that I was on to something with this idea, then how did Relativity relate to it?  If time was nothing more than a changing, moving universe, then how could speed affect this? How did the constancy of the speed of light factor into this scenario?  How could extreme velocity actually bend time itself?  Well, I think I might possibly have an answer for that.  At the very least, I think I may be on the right track.

Let's say that you have a box on your desk.  This box is completely empty.  It's an absolute void inside, and let's say that the box is made from some hypothetical material that experiences no atomic processes whatsoever.  The box is completely static.  There is no change, no decay, no entropy.  Like our example of the static universe, time can only be measured for this box relative to the changes in the flux you experience.  You go to bed; you wake up; you go to work; you come home, and you say that the box has aged a day simply because it has arrived at this same moment in time with you.  It has endured changes in the flux that you have experienced as a day.  Time is not happening to the box itself.  Nothing is happening to the box.  Time is happening outside the box, and the box is merely persisting through these changes.  We can measure the duration of this persistence only in relation to what has occurred outside the box.  The sun goes up; the sun goes down.  Seasons change.  People grow old and grey.  And all the while the box...just...sits there.

Suppose we were to look at this box from a different perspective, say from the perspective of an observer standing on the sun.  To them, the box is not sitting still, but rather it is being transported around the sun by a different frame of reference.  This observer would have the additional benefit of marking the box's passage through time by tracking its course around the sun.  If you recall my addendum to part 7, then you'll remember the scheme of interlocking frames of motion I established, the Earth round the sun, the sun round the galaxy, the the galaxies speeding away from one another, and so on.  Just as an observer in any one of these frames of reference would calculate the speed and the position of the box's transport relative to themselves, so too would they calculate the box's duration by measuring it against the changes in the universe's dynamic flux as they observe them from their vantage point.

This is where we bring Relativity into the picture.  Suppose we took this box and placed it aboard a rocket racing away from you and the Earth at near the speed of light, and let's say that given the speed it's going and the time dilation effect predicted by relativity, that as a year passes here on Earth, you see only a day pass aboard the rocket.  Stop to closely consider how you would interpret this experience.  You wouldn't look at the rocket and say a day has passed.  You would look at the universe from your perspective and say that a year has passed, and you have observed a day aboard the rocket span the length of that year.  This is how you would draw the conclusion that time was running slower aboard the rocket.  You would literally see things happening slower there.

Something curious happens though, if you focus exclusively on the box.  Considered in isolation, there is no meaningful way that you can say time is happening slower for the box.  There is no meaningful way that you can say that only a day has passed for the box.  As we established above, time is not happening to the box at all.  The only meaningful way that you can measure the box's duration is by comparing it to the passage of time that you've witnessed its persistence.  So, whether the box is sitting here at your desk, or rocketing away from you at the speed of light, you're forced to reach the same conclusion.  You've witnessed the persistence of this box for a year.  The only difference is that the box on the rocket has the misfortune of being imbedded in an extremely slowed environment.  The box itself has avoided the time dilation effect by virtue of its own immobility.  Possibly this is because technically you haven't witnessed time slowing down aboard the rocket, but rather you've witnessed the uniform slowing of all motion within that frame of reference to compensate for the relative velocity.  However, since, in the wave model, time and motion are interdependent, and the slowing is completely uniform and consistently even throughout the frame of reference from the tiniest particle to the most fleeting thought, you would still be completely accurate in saying that time aboard the rocket has slowed relative to you.  You might see a clock slowing down aboard the rocket, but that is literally and exactly what you're seeing, just a slowed clock.  And yet, you're also seeing it as evidence of slowed time.  A clock tracks the passage of time, but yet the motion of the clock itself is also a manifestation of time.

Click to Enlarge
This is just a first step, and it's all just speculation at this point, and to be clear I'm not trying to claim that there is some error or misconception in the theory of relativity.  I'm not trying to second guess Einstein.  I think even he would agree that slowed time would manifest itself to the observer as slowed motion.  Imagine being on Earth and watching a single day aboard that rocket transpire over a year.  Imagine how slowly you'd see someone perform their morning shave.  But the questions remain.  Is the time dilation caused by the slowed motion, or is the slowed motion encapsulated by the time dilation?  Is there more to it than than this, other factors?  How does near light travel relate to this? If time is interconnected with motion, then doesn't it made a certain sense that extreme motion might affect time?  Anyway, we'll see what happens down the road.        

Sunday, December 26, 2010

Trying to Understand Relativity (part 6)

This relativity business is pretty confusing.  I've been thinking that my thought experiment might be a little easier to follow if I made it a little less abstract.  With that in mind, I think that I should give the people in house A and house B actual names and identities.  We'll call the guy in house B "Bob", and we'll call the person in house A "Ann".  Yep, the person in house A was a woman the whole time!  Bam! That's what they call a plot twist.  Bet you didn't see that coming.  You see, Ann had just called Bob to tell him that she was lonely and wanted him badly.  That's why he was pushing the light barrier to get over to her house.  It all makes sense now.

Please.  No comments about the Freudian symbolism in this picture.
So anyhow, when we last left these two, I had just made a nice break in the case.  I had said that if Bob made the trip between the two houses at a speed which allowed him to cross the light-year between them in a year and one day, then it would appear to Ann that he was making the trip in one day, unless you accounted for the constant velocity of light.  By taking that into account, time itself would have to expand.  I speculated that the trip would have to take 365 years from Ann's perspective to keep her view of the image of Bob's ship from exceeding the speed of light.  (If this sentence sounds like gibberish to anyone new here, please refer to the Relativity tab above.  It'll probably still sound like gibberish after that, but you'll have the satisfaction of reading 5 other pages of gibberish.)       

I want to try something to test the math here.  It's not that I absolutely need to know the math.  I'm not going for a PhD in relativistic physics.  I'm just trying to grasp the basic concept.  But if I can check my idea against the percentage of distortion that relativity actually predicts, then I'll know if I'm on the right track.  

Okay, let's say we slowed Bob down to a speed where he was crossing a light year in a year and 6 months.  That would put him at about 75% of the speed of light.  Without taking the constancy of light into account, the trip would appear to Ann to take 6 months.  This means that she would have to see the ship coming towards her at twice the speed of light.  Now then, going by what I said last time, in order for her vision of the ship not to exceed the speed of light then the trip would have to take 2 years from her perspective.   That makes the trip 1 year and six months for Bob, and two years for Ann, and the ratio of distortion would be  approximately 1:1.3 at 75% the speed of light.

So this is basically what I'm doing here: I'm considering how many times faster than the speed of light Ann would have to see Bob's ship going for her to witness the trip without any time distortion.  Then I'm multiplying that number by a year, because there's one light year of distance, so light at it's constant speed should take a year to cross that distance.  Then I'm comparing that result to the time it actually takes Bob to make the trip.  In that manner, I'm coming up with a ratio between time for Bob and time for Ann that expresses the distortion mathematically.  Again, in this case 1:1.3 at 75% the speed of light.

At this point, I feel like I've thrown this whole thing together with duct tape.  It can't be right, can it?  Well, check out this handy little chart showing the distortion courtesy of Zayini at wikimedia commons:

I was forced to attribute this picture at gunpoint.  Sorry.
The numbers running up the left of the graph show the ratio of distortion, while the numbers running along the bottom show the percentage of the speed of light.  You can see that between 70 and 80% the curve hits at around the 1.5 mark.   So I'm a little off.  My formula is predicting that Bob's 18 month journey will take 24 months from Ann's point of view, but the chart is suggesting that the journey would take 27 months from Ann's perspective.   I'm off by three months.  That might not seem like much, but it definitely shows that my formula is wrong.  

Last time I think I got a clear glimpse of the time distortion.  I can at least see not how it's possible.  Progress is being made.  But I've still got some work to do, figuring the finer details of how it works.  The thing to focus on now is how Bob's 18 month journey at 75% of the speed of light can come out to be 27 months for Ann.  This handy chart is telling me the result I'm supposed to get.  I just have to come up with an understanding which produces this result.  Should be pretty simple, right?   

Thoughts?  Anyone?             

Thursday, November 18, 2010

Trying to Understand Relativity (part 4)

So, let's return to our thought experiment.  I mentioned last time that I found a flaw in the scenario I laid out in part 2.  I had my houses a light year apart and I put the guy from house B aboard a rocket on Jan. 1st 2010 and sent him to visit his neighbor in house A at nearly the speed of light (figure 1).  Considering the constancy of the speed of light, I thought I had found a clue to the time dilation effect of special relativity.  I said that if the guy in house A watched from his window, he wouldn't see guy B leave from his house until 2011 because of the time it took the light to reach him.  Furthermore, I said if guy A stayed at his window and continued to watch the journey, he wouldn't see guy B at the midpoint of his trip until June of 2011, because from his vantage point the trip began on Jan. 1st 2011 and it would take another six months for guy B to reach the midpoint.  Therefore, I concluded that guy B couldn't arrive on Jan. 1st. 2011, as I had originally thought, because he couldn't be sitting in guy A's house while guy A was still at the window watching him make the trip.  He couldn't arrive until 2012, after guy A had spent a year watching him make the trip.  So guy B would leave on Jan. 1st 2010, fly for a year at near the speed of light, but yet he wouldn't arrive at his destination until 2012.  

Figure 1.
However, I soon found a problem with this.  If guy B leaves for his journey on Jan. 1st 2010, then he reaches the midpoint of his trip in June of 2010.  At that point he is half a light year from house A, so the light from his ship will take six months to reach house A arriving on...yep, Jan. 1st 2011 not June as I had figured last time.  In fact, if you consider guy B's position at any point in his trip, the light will always arrive at house A on Jan. 1st 2011.  For instance, guy B will reach the 3/4 mark in September 2010.  He will be a quarter of a light year away, and the light will reach house A once again on Jan. 1st. 2011.  So it seems that guy B can still arrive on Jan. 1st 2011 and not beat the light there.  It seems that we're right back where we started from.

Will my efforts to understand Relativity be forever frustrated by my inadequate abilities to use the MS Paint program???
But yet there's a fundamental contradiction here.  What would guy A see from his window then?  He can't see guy B zip across the distance between their houses in a matter of seconds.  That would violate the whole idea of light traveling at a constant speed.  Guy A can't see guy B coming towards him faster than the speed of light.  It's impossible.  As I explained last time, light travels at the same speed regardless of its source.  So guy A's persistent vision of guy B's ship absolutely cannot look like it's traveling across the space between their houses at faster than the speed of light.  

For the sake of argument, let's say that guy B is traveling at a percentage of the speed of light that would land him at guy A's doorstep at the very last minute of the day on Jan. 1st 2011.  In other words, he's traveling at a speed where he crosses a light year in a year and one day.  If guy A were watching this from his window, and the light were reaching him from the different points in guy B's journey in the manner laid out above, he would see the rocket cross the distance of a light year in one day.  The persistent vision of the ship would have to reach him at 365 times the speed of light!   

Wow, that pickle is really Cruising!!!
So here you have two seemingly logical explanations that are yielding different results.  If you consider it from a static viewpoint, if you consider guy B at any one specific point in his journey, then you have the light reaching guy A on Jan. 1st 2011.  But if you look at it from dynamic viewpoint, if you put guy A at the window watching the whole thing in motion from the window then...then time has to expand to accommodate the speed of light!  In fact, the faster guy B races over to meet his neighbor, the more time will expand to compensate.  If guy B travels at the speed suggested above, a light year in a year and one day, then for guy A to watch the trip from his window and not have his persistent vision of the ship exceed the speed of light, then I believe that the trip would have to take 365 years from his point of view.  Yes, quite a long beard indeed!

Alright, so I may have it, and I may not.  It's a little early to pop the cork on the champagne just yet.  I'm still going to go back and read Einstein's original work as fellow blogger Martin Redford suggested yesterday.  A suggestion so obvious, I feel like an idiot for not doing it before.  Still, I thank him for his help.  Anyway, I'll read Einstein, see what I find, see if I've really made a break-through here or whether I'm still completely lost.                            

Wednesday, October 27, 2010

Trying to Understand Relativity (part 3)

Before taking yet another crack at Relativity, I tried to do a little "research" this time, which basically means I Googled "understanding relativity" and clicked on a bunch of links, read a bunch of articles, followed some of Google's suggested, related searches, and so on.  Not that I've always taken such a lazy, haphazard approach to the subject.  I've actually read a few books on relativity in the past.  But the problem has always been the same.  It's this problem that lead me to writing these posts in the first place.  All of these sources do a fine job of explaining the way that relativity works, but they never really tell me how or why it works that way....At least, not to my satisfaction.  Maybe I'm just missing something. Examples like the Twin Paradox merely demonstrate the fact of time dilation.  Yes, when the twin in the ship gets home his brother is older than him, I get it.  Yes, it's amazing and mind blowing and all that, but I want to know why.  

Maybe I need to have a clearer definition of what I mean by that.  I'm sure someone could sit me down and explain the math to me with a bunch of crazy equations involving triangles and italic letters until I was sure that I was about to have a brain aneurysm, and who knows, maybe that's what it takes to even have a basic understanding of it.  Maybe I'm totally out of my league on this one.  But I'm hoping that there's a way to comprehend the concept itself without getting deep into the technical details.  I'd like to imagine that someone could give me a satisfying explanation of how an air conditioner works without having to resort to wiring schematics and a chart showing the molecular configuration and chemical composition of the refrigerating agent.  I just want a brief description of how the damn thing makes cold air.  Am I asking too much?

Of course relativity is a bit more complicated that an air conditioner, I realize that.  I guess I'm trying to understand how the idea first occurred to Einstein.  There had to be a moment before he worked out all the math and the details when he looked at the constant speed of light, relative motion, space, and time and saw the first hints of his theory.  There had to be a moment when the simple genesis of the idea made sense, and he knew he was on to something.  I guess that's the moment I'm trying to return to.  I want to take those same elements and figure out how someone could see relativity there.  Nowadays relativity has been tested and confirmed and it has a solid place in the annals of scientific history.  But what if somehow all evidence of it completely disappeared and it somehow vanished from the public consciousness?  How could someone rediscover the idea from scratch?  How could they work it out from the elements involved?

This may seem like a pointless line of speculation and waste of time.  It must sound odd the way I'm putting it.  I'm not talking about reinventing relativity, or trying to forensically recreate Einstein's mental processes.  I'm talking about the core understanding of a basic idea.  Let me put it like this, let's say you wanted to understand how fire is made.  You read some books, you search the internet, and yet you keep seeing the same thing.  They all just keep saying, "Rub two sticks together and voila!"  But that's not what you want to know.  You want to know why rubbing the two sticks together makes fire.  So then they tell you, "Well it's all based on this guy's theory of rubbing sticks together."  So at that point, you say, "Well, what if that guy never existed.  What would make a person look at two sticks and think that rubbing them together would make fire?  What if we had to figure it out for ourselves?"  

This is where I feel like I'm at with relativity.  I don't know why I bother.  It just frustrates me not to be able to understand it.  Like I said, maybe I'm just in over my head.  Maybe I should just humbly accept my limitations and move on.  Really, it's not even the whole theory I'm trying to grasp.  Obviously, most of my speculation has focused on the time-dilation effect, which is only a very small part of the theory.  Not that the concept of gravity being caused by mass warping space is any picnic to try to understand either, but I'm not even close to ready to open that can of worms yet.                                            

Anyway, I hope to get things back on track with my next post on the subject.  I guess I got off on a bit of a tangent here.  I'll return to my two neighboring houses next time, and maybe have some new ideas on how to approach the whole thing.  Almost immediately upon hitting the "publish" button on my last relativity post, I noticed a possible flaw in my scenario.  At first glance it seemed as though this flaw might undo any progress I might have made and put me right back at square one with guy B's trip seeming instantaneous to the guy in house A.  However, after considering the matter, I think this "flaw" might actually point to a way through, rather than a step back.  I'm still working it out, though.  

Next time?

Friday, October 8, 2010

Trying to Understand Relativity (part 2)

At the risk of my sanity, I'm taking another crack at trying to understand relativity.  Last time I set up a thought experiment (figure 1) that involved two neighboring houses that were a light year apart.  I placed the guy in house B aboard a spaceship and sent him to visit the guy in house A.  The end result was that it appeared (to my limited understanding at least) that the trip would seem instantaneous to the guy in house A.  Because of the time it would take for the light from house B to reach him, the guy in house A wouldn't see his neighbor board his ship until 2011. Seconds later the neighbor would be knocking at the door.  This result seemed to be the direct opposite of what I've always been told about relativity.  

Figure 1.
I think that one problem is that I failed to take the constancy of the speed of light into consideration.  Basically, I left the relativity out of relativity.  Light behaves strangely when it comes to the speed at which it travels.  This behavior seems to run contrary to common sense.  If you're in your car at night and you have the headlights on, the light from those bulbs travels at the speed of light.  Now, as you press on the gas and speed up to sixty miles an hour, it would appear that the light should travel at the speed of the light PLUS the sixty miles an hour that the car is going.  Since the source of the light itself is being propelled at sixty miles an hour, then the light should reach an observer, say someone standing on a hill a mile down the road, that much faster...right?  But that's not what happens.  It turns out that the light travels at the exact same speed regardless of the velocity of its source.  So something has to give....time.   

Generally, this doesn't make much difference in our everyday lives and at the normal speeds that we travel, but when you're talking about a craft moving at near light velocities, this point becomes significant.  So that brings me back to my thought experiment.  Now let's suppose that the guy in house A stands at his window, watching the entire trip as his neighbor crosses the distance between their houses.  

Is that a Flying Pickle?
Now, as I mentioned last time, although the guy in house B leaves in 2010, the guy in house A doesn't see him leave and start his journey until 2011.  Since the guy from house B was travelling at 99.99999% the speed of light, and since the distance between the houses was exactly one light year, I figured that the trip would take just a little over a year.  So you have the guy in house A seeing the trip begin in 2011, and then guy from house B arriving in 2011 just a few seconds later. Quick trip, right?  But again, let's put the guy from house A at his window, watching the trip.  Now, at any certain point along the line, the light from the ship is travelling at the speed of light and it takes that amount of time to reach guy A at his window.  So, at let's say...the half point of the journey, the light from the ship is going to take 6 months to reach guy A at his window.

Now, at this point, it's at least June 2011 when guy A sees his neighbor at the half point of his journey.  So the guy from house B can't arrive at his doorstep in January 2011 if the guy from house A is still standing at his window watching him make the trip.  Guy B can't exceed the speed of light, so he can't reach his destination before the light does.  He can't be sitting in guy A's living room, sipping coffee and reminiscing about old times, while his ship is still out there making the trip.  This, I think, is where the time dilation comes into effect.

It would seem then, that at the very earliest, the guy from house B can't arrive on the doorstep of house A until January 2012.  As you recall, this would be 2 years after he started out from his driveway, even though only a year passed for him aboard the ship.  So while Guy A is two years older, his neighbor has only aged one.  I think I'm getting closer to understanding it all, but I don't think I'm quite there yet. 

For one thing, I believe that relativity suggests that the time dilation would be far more extreme that what I've laid out in this scenario.  I think that maybe the guy in house A should have a long white beard when his neighbor finally arrives.  I'm not sure.  At that close to the speed of light, guy A should perhaps see time aboard the ship slow down to almost a halt as it speeds along the cutting edge of light itself.  Maybe that one year aboard the ship would stretch and span across guy A's time line exponentially.  I don't know.  I've taken the matter as far as I can at the moment.

Am I making progress?

To be continued?
    

Sunday, September 19, 2010

Trying to Understand Relativity (part 1)

I've always been intrigued by the theory of relativity, but I really have a hard time wrapping my head around the whole concept.  I'd like to think I'm smart enough to understand it, but after ten minutes of thinking about it, I start to feel like that famous railroad worker that had a tamping rod driven through his skull.  I understand how it all works to some degree, but I don't understand why.  I know that the discovery that light travels at a constant rate irregardless of the velocity of the source emitting or reflecting the light contributed to Einstein's development of the theory in some way.  I know all about the time dilation and the Twin Paradox and everything.  I just can't quite grasp the way it all works.  I've tried to devise a kind of thought experiment to help me understand, but I think I'm clearly missing something.

Figure 1.

Alright, so you have these two houses.  They are both separated by a distance of one light year (figure 1).  It's 2010 at both houses, but because of the time it takes for the light to reach each neighbor, when they look out at each other they're both seeing the state that each existed in back in 2009.  

Figure 2

Okay, so now let's say that in 2010 the guy in house B decides to visit the guy in house A.  He gets into his spaceship and travels at as near the speed of light as it's possible to get (figure 2).  Since the distance is one light year, it will take him just over a year to make the trip.  So he'll arrive at house A in 2011.  Okay, now let's say that the guy in house A has been standing at his window watching all this.  Again, since it takes a year for the light to travel, the guy in house A doesn't see his neighbor in house B pull his spaceship out of his garage until 2011.  Then, a mere few minutes later, he gets a knock at his door.  His neighbor from house B has just arrived on his doorstep.

So doesn't it seem like the trip would seem nearly instantaneous to the guy in house A?  Yet, everything I've ever heard about relativity seems to suggest the opposite.  They say that if the guy in house A could see a clock aboard his neighbor's spaceship it would seem to slow down.  If the guy from house B could see a clock in the living room of house A from aboard his ship, it would seem to race by.  But it seems almost like it would be the other way around.  House A would see the clock zip along, spinning through a year of days in a matter of seconds.  Meanwhile, from the ship, the clock in house A would seem to slow down to compensate for the extra year.  (Remember, that the guy in house B sees house A as it was in 2009 when he climbs aboard his ship.)

I don't know.  The problem's obviously not with relativity, but rather with my understanding of it.  There's either something fundamentally flawed or missing in my experiment, or my idea of relativity itself is completely backward.  I don't get it.

I need some aspirin.
         
Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...